Sacramental Living

I was reminded recently by a blogging friend, Scott Savage, of John Wesley’s response to this question. The question itself seems condemning enough if it comes from a “Christian.” Wesley’s response is plain, simple, and beautiful.

“John Wesley recognized the ambiguities of Matthew 25:31-46 but did not allow them to deter him from responding to persons in need. To those who wondered ‘what does it avail to feed or clothe men’s bodies, if they are just dropping into everlasting fire?’ Wesley responded, ‘whether they will finally be lost or saved, you are expressly commanded to feed the hungry, and clothe the naked. If you can, and do not, whatever becomes of them, you shall go away into everlasting fire.’ He strongly resisted any attempts to narrow the scope of responsibility or to dull the intensity of the passage.”

From Christine D. Pohl, Making Room: Recovering Hospitality as a Christian Tradition

–

Brian Niece
www.brianniece.com
If you enjoyed this post, get free updates by email or RSS.

Cavanaugh has regularly been a voice of dissent in the face of accepted cultural norms of post-modernism.  Yet, his is not a pessimistic voice, but a voice that speaks into the hope of God’s reconciling and redeeming work.

This little gem of a book is an easy read; quite unlike his previous Torture and Eucharist.  There are certain strains of familiarity with Marva J. Dawn’s Unfettered Hope.

Cavanaugh argues that our general notions of globalism and consumerism have been waterd down.  Or better yet, they have been too narrow.

In the face of globalism, Cavanaugh paints a Christian communal response that honors the particular in the macrocosms of cultural.

The bottom line is that we do not have an appropriate theology of God’s abundance.  Cavanaugh essentially seeks to answer the question, “Do we really believe God provides his people with all they need to be his people?”

If the answer is “Yes” then we have a different paradigm and story from which to live.  God’s Economy tells a different story with different practices and different reference points.

SO TELL ME SOMETHING:
Have you read the book?  What have you learned about God’s economy?

——

Brian Niece
www.brianniece.com
If you enjoyed this post, get free updates by email or RSS.

I just finished “Pagan Christianity: Exploring the Roots of our Church Practices” by Frank Viola and George Barna.

My, my, my … many theoretical problems with this book.

The historical study is very accurate and quite fascinating. The analysis and synthesis of the authors’ conclusions lead to a fallacy in method. They are prescribing a practice of the Church (and church, little “c”) that essentially does what they have accused the Church of historically doing: erecting human practices on scriptural grounds. Their methodology is flawed.

Though they argue for the full tenor of scripture, they do not grasp how that understanding is put into practice.

The authors’ criticism is leveled primarily at low-church Protestantism. And unfortunately, there is no talk of the redeeming and reconciling nature of the work of the gospel through Christian practices.

Everything they describe as organic church, I experience in my faith community. Yet, we own a building, we have paid staff, etc. We don’t play dress up on Sunday, nor some of the other things the authors find non-Biblical. But we do intend toward community: meaning our community is intentional.

Many of the criticisms of the book did not hit home with me. It seems that Viola and Barna have found a wonderfully subversive way to sell a lot of copies of a book. But in so doing they are misconstruing the analysis and pigeon-holing the possible practical implications their historicity affords.

For my part, I just listed the book in brand new condition at half.com … though I feel a bit bad to have someone else pay for it. At least it won’t continue to line the authors’ pockets.

SO TELL ME SOMETHING:
Have you read the book? What are your thoughts on the authors’ methodology?

——

Brian Niece
www.brianniece.com
If you enjoyed this post, get free updates by email or RSS.